Vol. 1, No. 13 | Toronto, Ontario | News & features from the good food revolution

Home Subscribe GFR Blog About Contact

Thanksgiving Cheese Plate
by Andy Shay

As an American, used to Thanksgiving as a warm up for Christmas, I love that Canadian Thanksgiving is firmly embedded in the harvest season – the best time of year. Tell me that the last month has not been the best weather that we have had all summer. I only hope it will stay that way for the holiday.

Of course, there is always a cheese platter at my Thanksgiving table, and this is what we will be eating this year. For me harvest cheeses are firmer, nuttier, stronger flavoured cheeses that stand up to the beautiful, but slightly cooler and windy days of the early fall. Here is a guide to how I put my board together.

How Many?
When I assemble a platter I like to choose five to six cheeses, and not more than 200g of any one. This allows for different tastes and is a visual queue to your guests that these are fine cheeses to savour, not just to wolf down. Besides, have any of your guests really ever gone hungry or not had enough food from your table on Thanksgiving?

Put it on, dress it up
Next, the platter. Since this is a harvest holiday I think that something natural like wood works very well to set the tone and to show the cheeses of to their best advantage. I could also see a tile or rough stone or hand thrown ceramic plate. For decoration, I step into the garden and find whatever is at hand, whatever the season brings – or go for a walk in a ravine, or if you are lucky enough to be in the country head for your nearest field or forest au current mementos of the season.

Accompaniments
For this cheese board I headed to About Cheese at Church and Wellesley in Toronto, because they specialize in Canadian cheeses and because they have a great selection of Canadian varietal honeys. I am not sure why, but only the beekeepers of Quebec seem to have figured out how wonderful varietal honey truly is – an art that the Europeans have know for centuries. They are honeys that are collected from fields of predominantly one flower. As soon as the flower fades, the honey is extracted from the combs, a more labour intensive process with delicious results. Years ago when I had my store, Shay Gourmet, I discovered Rucher des Framboisiers brand of varietal honeys from the Gaspe – About Cheese is the only place that I can find it in Toronto and it is worth the schlep to Church Street. Today, I chose a golden rod honey, medium coloured, as a late summer flower, just right for these heartier cheeses. It smells of honey and melted comb, but there is something thicker, richer, more caramelly and sweeter in the aroma. On the tongue it is sharply sweet, tastes of berries and has an edge. $12.95/500g

Nuts - choose any, almonds, walnuts or pecans, just be sure to toast them to bring out the flavours – it will make all the difference in flavour.

Apples – The apples are never better than right now, I just had some amazing honey crisps. Just set them whole right on the board and let your guests cut their own slices.

Honey and apples, honey and cheese, cheese and honey, cheese and apples, whatever way you put them together, it is a brilliant combination.

The cheeses
These cheeses are largely new to the market, with the exception of Noyan. Let’s give thanks for them!

1608
Named after the year the Canadienne cow, developed as an all purpose bovine for the tough Canadian climate was first brought to Canada. How could you resist this cheese on name alone? It is a celebration of Quebec history (produced in the Charlevoix) and Canada all at once – perfect symbolically for Thanksgiving. And then there is the flavour, think Comte, Beaufort, Morbier and you will be on the right track. It is semi firm, has a acidic aroma and a lovely nuttiness on the tongue – not sharp at all, just delightful.

Noyan
This was one of the first Quebec cheeses that I ever tasted and it is still a favourite. Made just south of Montreal near the US border in the town of Noyan. Fromager Fritz Kaiser turns his considerable native Swiss cheesemaking skills to goat cheese and this is the delicious result. A firm cheese with a white washed rind, gentle, but deeply nutty aroma and on the tongue? A touch of bitterness, then balanced saltiness, then a long and lasting high noted nuttiness. Your guests will have a difficult time guessing that this is a goat cheese.

Alexandria
From the hand of Margaret Morris, just north of Cornwall Ontario, the cheese is named after the nearby town. This washed rind cheese has an orange rind and is semisoft. It is slightly sticky and is definitely stinky – earthy, like a rotting log. Ooh, my... lovely big flavour. Immediately and lasting on the tongue is something deliciously burnt. There is a hint of sweetness, seaweediness and always that underlying burnt flavour. The rind is sandy in the teeth, and juxtaposes nicely with the smooth interior.

Mouton Rouge
Cheese maker Elizabeth Bizikot in Conn, Ontario produces this sheep cheese and it is gentle and complex. The cheese has a lovely white and the mouldy rind is rumpled, a testament to its hand-made status. It is a fairly dry cheese on the tongue, and seemingly mild at first but it flairs in the nasal passages with every breath – distinctive sheep milk flavour.

Smoked Cheddar
As Provincial Fine Foods takes steps into the business of affinage (or "finishing" cheese), they have produced a new cheese from an old favourite. It all starts with 2 year Ile-aux-Grues Cheddar – a lovely example of a very versatile cheese that has long been a favourite of mine - and they smoke it. If you like smoked cheese, the aroma is tantalizing and strong from the moment you open the package. The rind has a delightfully smoky flavour that is varied and fine – not unlike fine smoked salmon – you have tasted the difference, right? The interior has less flavour but still has a lovely edge of smokiness.

Bleu d'Elizabeth
This blue from Fromagerie Presbytere, near the Gaspe is a relatively new blue cheese from Quebec. It is soft and creamy, with the occasional granular nubble. The blue is rich, almost sweet, but not sharp. The veins are a deep blue. Blue cheese lovers and even those who don’t, are sure to enjoy this cheese.

Andy Shay is a Toronto-based cheese expert and consultant. Learn about Andy's tutored tastings at AndyShay.com

Copyright © Jolsand Enterprises Ltd. 2009. All rights reserved. All enquiries: info@goodfoodrev.com.